Sunday, September 22, 2013

Is it Moys the right choice for United?

Having succeeded Sir Alex Ferguson as United manager this summer, Moyes has now seen the champions win just two of their first five league games, with his team suffering potentially costly defeats against traditional rivals City and Liverpool.
David Moyes demands reaction from Manchester United players after Premier League defeat to Manchester City
United, without groin injury victim Robin van Persie, were accused by Manchester City captain Vincent Kompany of not wanting to win the game as much Manuel Pellegrini’s team.
After suffering the ignominy of being outplayed and outfought by City, Moyes admitted that he told his players their performance was not up to standard.
“I’ve made them aware of that,” Moyes said. “But if ever there was a group of players I’d expect a reaction from it would be a group of Manchester United players.
“I think the way they have been brought up, the way they have been bred with the manager previously, they react, that’s what they do, and that’s what we will do here.I just told the players it the way I would have told players at any other club if I don’t think they are doing it.
“They are good players, good pros, and they know when they’re bang at it and when they’re not. We’ll make sure we react.”
Having surrendered the title to United last season – a campaign which included a 3-2 defeat against Ferguson’s team at the Etihad Stadium – City captain Kompany insisted that the home side were more determined to emerge victorious.
“Maybe the game meant a little bit more to us than for them,” Kompany said. “We were looking forward to this fixture. But it’s too early to say it’s a defining game. You make a statement over the course of the season, but it would be silly to give away three precious points.
“When we won 6-1 at Old Trafford I said we need to stay humble. It’s only three points, but it’s a good game to win and it gives the fans something to celebrate over the next few days.”
City manager Manuel Pellegrini, like Moyes taking charge of his first Manchester derby, maintained his unbeaten record against United following four draws while manager Villarreal. But after guiding his team to victory, the Chilean claimed that the result could be a damaging blow to United’s morale.
“It could be very big,” Pellegrini said. “Winning against Manchester United and the way we did is always important. It was a very important result. You normally don’t expect to win 4-1 against United, but the most important thing after the win is the way we played. Maybe United couldn’t play better because we played so well.”
United’s defeat, one day short of the 24th anniversary of a 5-1 defeat at Maine Road, extended their run of failing to score from open play in the league since the opening day victory at Swansea.
Wayne Rooney’s late free-kick, which made him the all-time leading scorer in Manchester derbies with eleven goals, was the sum total of United’s attacking play and Moyes admitted to being concerned by his team’s failure to create, and score, more goals.
“Yes, a little bit,” Moyes said. “I thought we created a few chances later on in the game, albeit the game was probably won by Manchester City at that point. There was no reason for us not to perform well today, but it’s one game, there are plenty more to come and plenty of time for us to try to fix it.
“I think our squad is really strong. Obviously you miss Robin van Persie, it’s a huge miss to anybody, but I thought Wayne could arguably have been the best player on the pitch today. He certainly didn’t deserve to play in the losing team, that’s for sure. I thought he was outstanding and it was probably as good a Wayne Rooney as I have seen.”
United face Liverpool at Old Trafford in the Capital One Cup on Wednesday and Moyes, who admitted he has not yet considered whether to rest players for that fixture, admitted Van Persie could feature against Brendan Rodgers’ team.
“I don’t think his injury is that bad,” Moyes said. “We felt he was going to make it but he just felt something in his groin.
“He’d actually done some training in the last couple of days but he just felt it when he made any sharp movements and didn’t want to aggravate it so we took that decision.”

Manchester United worst start to a season in almost a decade.

Manchester United worst start to a season in almost a decade.



Much will be made of the fact Manchester United were missing Robin van Persie through injury during Sunday's sensational derby humiliation at the hands of Manchester City but that would be an insult to the outstanding performance of the home team at the Etihad Stadium.From the defensive organisation of fit-again captain Vincent Kompany, to the midfield purpose and goalscoring of Yaya Toure and Samir Nasri, along with the finishing of Sergio Aguero - Manuel Pellegrini's City were superb in their manager's derby debut.


United, in contrast, were decimated and have now taken just seven points from their opening five Premier League games. It was always going to be a tough start when also hosting Chelsea and a trip to Liverpool but the pressure is unquestionably on David Moyes after his painful own first taste of the derby.


Here, Peter Fraser uses Opta statistics to pick apart City's crushing 4-1 victory and looks at what went wrong for an annihilated United in the biggest setback so far of the defending champions' post-Sir Alex Ferguson era.Van Persie was missing from the United squad for the eagerly anticipated derby in what was a huge blow for the visitors at the Etihad. The prolific Dutchman's name was conspicuous by its absence due to a groin injury as the teams were announced, with his place being taken by Danny Welbeck. Van Persie was not even among the substitutes while Ashley Young was also included in the side for Shinji Kagawa.City made just one change from the side who launched their Champions League campaign with victory over Viktoria Plzen in midweek, with striker Alvaro Negredo replacing Edin Dzeko. That meant captain Kompany kept his place having only returned from injury in the European win last Tuesday.City had a clear intent to not let United settle into the game and they were full of intensity from kick-off. They enjoyed a 70.6 per cent dominance of possession in the opening 15 minutes and pushed United deep into their own territory while at the same time focusing their attacks on the left-hand side.This exact tactic led to Aguero's opening goal, which had manager Pellegrini punching the air in delight on the touchline. Antonio Valencia was presumably selected by United for his work ethic and defensive commitment on the right of United's attacking players. But he switched off in the 16th minute to let Aleksandar Kolarov overlap Nasri and cross for Aguero to supply a sublime, volleyed finish.City continued to enjoy themselves with a majority share of possession and they produced nine shots in the opening quarter of the game, with United failing to manage one. United undoubtedly caused themselves problems throughout their ineffective performance but likewise the purpose and power of City was immense.Man of the match Yaya Toure and the rejuvenated Nasri, who was also superb in the midweek win over Plzen, were significant factors in City's excellent first half. Toure touched the ball 43 times, won all of his two duels and played 38 passes, the most of any player on the pitch, at a pass success rate of 86.8%. He also scored City's second goal on the stroke of half-time after a defensive lapse from Marouane Fellaini, who lost his man. Likewise, Nasri touched the ball 46 times, which was the most of any man on either side in the first half.


For United, although they saw an increase in possession in the 10 minutes before half-time - with the possession stats at the break reading only a 54.7% majority for City - there were familiar signs from their season. They had the ball in central areas but Michael Carrick and Fellaini were failing to dictate play. Carrick won possession (10) and had more touches (95) than any other player over the course of the game. But as Sky Sports' Gary Neville identified in co-commentary, there were "too many straight passes". Fellaini was supposed to improve this area after taking Tom Cleverley's place in the team but there was little impact against City.Carrick and Fellaini were failing to play the ball at any angles which would test City's line of defence and this in turn allowed the home side to keep their shape and mean Wayne Rooney, who looked a frustrated figure, had to drop deep in search of the ball. Young was also guilty of a dire performance, with only eight successful passes before half-time.


Sky Sports' Niall Quinn said at the interval: "Manchester City have been outstanding in all departments. Matching up man-to-man, they have totally dominated Manchester United. The intricacy of their play and the spirit and desire at the back to win tackles has been lovely to watch at times. They deservedly lead 2-0."United were, of course, missing Van Persie but Welbeck was having to work off scraps in place of the influential Dutchman as the lone striker. It is difficult to imagine whether Van Persie would have been able to do any better. Welbeck touched the ball just 15 times in the first half, which was the same as City goalkeeper Joe Hart and that provided a microcosm of the game.Little changed immediately after half-time, when City made it 3-0 in a goal which was spookily similar to the first, with Valencia guilty of allowing Kolarov to overlap with a decoy run. Nasri had the room to cross for Negredo who in turn centred the ball for Aguero to finish with another volley after running off the back of Fellaini. It could be argued deadline-day signing Fellaini is not yet up to speed with United's defensive tactics unlike City's summer signings, who all arrived early in the window.

If midfield effectiveness had been a boxing contest, the United coaching staff would surely have thrown in the towel given the way their side were being pulled apart. Again United's midfield was non-existent as City made it 4-0 in the 50th minute. Nasri scored the goal but Kompany took the credit after winning the ball on the edge of his box and feeding it to Jesus Navas before running the length of the pitch to create the space in United's box.It was a reflection of Kompany's overall performance. The Belgian may have only just returned from injury but he hardly gave Rooney or Welbeck a sniff of the ball. At the final whistle, Kompany had won five of his six duels, made 12 clearances - four times more than his closest team-mate - and had gained possession on nine occasions.

Moyes responded to going 4-0 down by sending on Cleverley in place of the hugely ineffective Young. The poor performance of Young can also be attributed to the fact he was facing Pablo Zabaleta, who underlined his reputation as the best right-back in the division after a superb 10 tackles overall, which was more than double any other player on the pitch.But the introduction of Cleverley made little impact. With three in central midfield, United saw a bit more of the ball. However, the key to City's success were the influential performances throughout their team, with Kompany, Toure, Nasri and Aguero, who was typically clinical with two goals from his only two shots in the game, all absolutely superb.

Rooney would at least give United, who have another tough match on Wednesday when Liverpool visit Old Trafford in the Capital One Cup, something to cheer with less than five minutes of normal time remaining when his wonderful, curling free-kick was out of reach of Hart. The goal was Rooney's 11th in a Manchester derby to mean he is now the highest scorer in the fixture's history. But landmarks and consolations will mean little to Moyes as he worries about any potential lasting hangover among his squad from their derby embarrassment.

Manchester derby

Manuel Pellegrini and David Moyes are making their debuts in a Manchester derby on Sunday and hoping their attacking threats outnumber the defensive weaknesses.

MANCHESTER CITY

Manager: Manuel Pellegrini

Like his opposite number, making his debut in a Manchester derby, though David Moyes has at least experienced the occasion in the past as a spectator. After four games it is fair to say that those who tipped Manchester City to run away with this season's title have been revising their expectations slightly downwards, for only the opening game was truly impressive and the manner of the unexpected defeat at Cardiff downright worrying. Courtesy of a much kinder Champions League group than City have been used to Pellegrini is up and running in Europe, though there is still uncertainty over his best team, particularly at the front end. On the positive side, there is plenty of room for improvement.

Defence

The meanest in the Premier League last season, leaking 34 goals, but still inexplicably flimsy whenever Vincent Kompany goes missing. Fortunately, the reliable Belgian is back from injury now, so City should not have too many defensive worries as long as Joe Hart can put his recent wobbles behind him. Joleon Lescott was so jittery in the last home match that Pellegrini paired Javi García with Matija Nastasic at centre-back for the visit to Stoke, where City were quite lucky to come away with a point, but with Kompany fit again the only area of doubt is left-back, where Gaël Clichy has been injured and Aleksandar Kolarov erratic.

Midfield

Yaya Touré is still the go-to man, both in terms of providing the drive from deep positions and, increasingly, getting among the goals. He has two in the league this season, although splendid as his late free-kick against Hull City in the last home match was, it put a flattering gloss on a very ordinary performance by his high standards. He was flat that day, and so were City, whereas when Touré is dominant in midfield his side are at their best. He has played every minute of every league game this season, making a total of 347 passes with an accuracy of more than 90%. City now have Fernandinho anchoring the midfield, and if the latest upgrade on Nigel de Jong has made a quiet start in England, at least Touré still has the attacking freedom he desires.

Attack

Still a work in progress, with Alvaro Negredo resembling Edin Dzeko, Jesús Navas establishing himself and Stevan Jovetic wondering where he will fit in. The main attacking threats are still the ones from the title-winning season, David Silva and Sergio Agüero, though a lack of goals became a worry last season, and Carlos Tevez has departed since then. While City are not quite as blunt up front as Chelsea, they sometimes suffer from a similar lack of directness in attack, and often need someone to take charge. That said, as United know very well, there are days when everything clicks and big scores can be run up. Even Dzeko can be devastating on his day.

MANCHESTER UNITED

Manager: David Moyes

The new Manchester United manager is nearing the end of a start so tough he complained about it, and with a draw at home to Chelsea and defeat at Anfield the derby result will determine whether or not his side will come out on the credit side of the ledger. A poor performance could undermine players' and supporters' confidence, though United managed to look a lot like their old selves in the Champions League in midweek against Bayer Leverkusen, and the club's management deserves recognition for sticking to their guns and their principles in the crisis Wayne Rooney tried to force. If that was the biggest test of all for Moyes he has come through it, and Rooney appears to be thriving on the humble pie diet.

Defence

Not at its most convincing in conceding two goals to a fairly unimpressive Bayer Leverkusen in midweek, though the second one of those was after Moyes had made a few substitutions with his side 4-1 up. Rio Ferdinand and Nemanja Vidic remain the first-choice centre-half pairing for occasions when experience and mental toughness are called for, though along with Patrice Evra they are not as nimble as they used to be and could be vulnerable to pace. City have real pace in Navas, though Pellegrini has also been sticking with a big fella up front in either Dzeko or Negredo, and United will be happy to deal with crosses.

Midfield

Eyebrows were raised at Moyes's acquisition of Marouane Fellaini from Everton and his somewhat lame excuse for paying £4m over the odds for the combative midfielder. The £27.5m capture has been rather more convincing since he turned up, slotting into a defensive role that allows him to break up opposing attacks while still moving forward for the occasional shot. He does not look out of place playing for United, has deceptively good control for a tall player, and his solidity alongside Michael Carrick allows the wide players in the side to push further up the field. Despite fewer minutes on the pitch he has made more tackles in league matches this season than Touré, though some of those were for Everton.

Attack

Now that Rooney appears content playing alongside Robin van Persie and even Sir Alex Ferguson has given his blessing to the partnership, United should cause problems for most defences. Makes you wonder what all the fuss was about really; had Ferguson played them in tandem against Real Madrid last season we might have been spared a summer of angst. Yet it was not just Rooney benched for that game, Shinji Kagawa was also left out. It was Danny Welbeck who played behind Van Persie, and United were doing pretty well until Nani's dismissal. Moyes has plenty of attacking options – he just needs time to find out what works best.